Robert Vis says he raised more than €1bn for Bird without a single euro from Dutch investors, and wants pension funds to spread €17.2bn over ten years into Dutch startups.
Credit: this report is based on a story first published by Quote. Read the original at quotenet.nl.
According to a column by Robert Vis published by Quote on 15 November, the money Bird raised in recent years came from Y Combinator, Accel, Atomico, Spark, Tiger Global, Eurazeo and BlackRock. Vis, the 42-year-old founder of Bird, who still lives in Amsterdam, puts the total at more than €1bn and the Dutch share at zero. He writes that nobody turned him down: there was simply nobody with a cheque that size to turn him down.
The cap tables he points to
Vis uses two other Dutch names to make his case. In Adyen's 2018 IPO prospectus, he writes, Index Ventures, General Atlantic, Temasek and Iconiq together held 41% of the shares, while recognisable Dutch money from outside the company held 6.6%. That stake, according to Vis, came partly from the legacy of Prince Friso, with no pension fund or bank among the holders.
Mollie, he writes, raised €780m without a cent from a Dutch pension provider or bank. In the software sector Vis counted more than twenty Dutch rounds of €50m or more since 2021, of which only one, the smallest, was led by a Dutch fund.
Pension money and the state
The column sets those cap tables against the size of Dutch pension assets, which Vis puts at €1.72tn. Citing the Ministry of Economic Affairs, he writes that at least €642m of that went to Dutch venture funds over five years, a share he calculates at 0.04%. Of the pension money those venture funds did raise in 2024, 60% came from North America, and ABP paid €1.1bn in fees to private equity firms last year, according to the column.
Vis is also critical of the state's role. Invest-NL has received €1.26bn of taxpayer money since 2020 and now shows a loss of more than €160m, he writes, while aiming for a 2% return. He adds that the state lends to startups at an interest rate of 7.19%, which he describes as banking rather than investing.
He does name one exception: Innovation Industries, backed by pension money from PME and PMT, led the February round of chip company Axelera.
The proposal
Vis closes with a calculation aimed at the people who manage the pension pot. If 1% of the €1.72tn, or €17.2bn, were spread over ten years, €1.72bn a year could go to Dutch startups. "Write that cheque," he tells them (translated from Dutch).
His advice to founders is to look to California for capital, where, in his words, investors take risk rather than talk about it.
Original source: Quote, "Robert Vis: 'Ik heb voor Bird ruim €1 miljard opgehaald. De Nederlandse inbreng? Nul'"





